free site statistics

The History Of The Pot Pie: A Comfort Food Journey


The History Of The Pot Pie: A Comfort Food Journey

Hey there! So, you know those nights when you just crave something warm, something hearty, something that feels like a hug in a bowl? Yeah, me too. And for me, that usually means one thing: a pot pie. But have you ever stopped to think, like, really stop and wonder, where did this magical concoction even come from?

It’s not exactly rocket science, right? Dough, filling, baked until golden. Simple, yet oh-so-satisfying. But like all good things, it has a history. A surprisingly long and, dare I say, interesting history. Grab your coffee, settle in, because we're going on a little journey through time, all thanks to this humble dish.

So, picture this: you're not in your cozy kitchen with your favorite streaming service. Nope. We're talking way, way back. Like, ancient times. Seriously. Turns out, the idea of wrapping food in pastry is basically as old as, well, baking itself. People have been figuring out how to make dough and put stuff in it for ages. Smart cookies, these ancestors of ours.

But the pot pie as we sort of know it? That’s a bit more specific. We’re talking about Europe, specifically medieval Europe. Imagine those big, drafty castles. Brrr. What do you think they needed to warm them up? You guessed it: hearty food.

And in those days, pastry wasn't just for dessert. Oh no. It was more like a handy, edible container. Think of it as the original Tupperware, but way tastier. They’d make these thick, frankly quite tough crusts, called 'coffins'. Catchy, right? Probably not the most appetizing name for our modern sensibilities, but it served a purpose.

These 'coffins' weren't meant to be eaten with the filling. Their main job was to protect the precious ingredients inside during long journeys or while being stored. So, a knight could take his meat and veggies wrapped in this sturdy pastry, and it would keep them from going bad. Brilliant, really. A practical, edible shield. Who needs a sword when you have a pastry coffin?

Pot Pie History at Elizabeth Simson blog
Pot Pie History at Elizabeth Simson blog

And the fillings? Oh, they were varied. Whatever was available, really. Game birds, meats, sometimes even fish. Think of it as a precursor to our modern stews, just… encased. Less gravy splash, more, you know, structural integrity.

But as time marched on, things started to change. People realized, "Hey, this pastry stuff is actually pretty darn good to eat!" Imagine that! The tough, protective crusts gradually became thinner, flakier, and altogether more delicious. It’s like they went from a cardboard box to a delicate puff pastry. A definite upgrade, wouldn't you say?

So, the idea of eating the crust along with the filling started to take hold. This is where we start getting closer to our beloved pot pie. The pastry became less of a shield and more of a delicious accompaniment. A fluffy, buttery hug for the savory goodness within. It was a culinary evolution, a tasty revolution!

Now, let’s talk about England. England and pies go together like, well, peas and carrots. Or maybe even better: gravy and mashed potatoes. Pot pies really took root there. They were a staple in homes, taverns, and even the grandest of banquets. The Victorians, bless their elaborate hearts, absolutely adored them. Imagine them, all dressed up, tucking into a rich, savory pie. Probably with a side of, you guessed it, more pie.

Home Comfort Chicken Pot Pie | thekitchenman | Wayne Conrad Serbu
Home Comfort Chicken Pot Pie | thekitchenman | Wayne Conrad Serbu

The 'pie' in 'pot pie' kind of refers to the deep dish, the generous portion. It wasn't just a little tart; it was a full-blown meal. And the fillings got more refined. Chicken, beef, lamb – all slow-cooked to perfection, nestled in a creamy sauce, and topped with that beautiful golden pastry lid. It sounds like pure comfort, doesn't it?

Think about those classic stories. Dickensian London. Dark, damp streets. What do you think people were dreaming of after a long day? A piping hot pot pie. It was the ultimate working-class comfort food. Affordable, filling, and utterly delicious. It’s the kind of food that sticks with you, both in your belly and in your heart.

Of course, the pot pie didn’t just stay put in England. It traveled! And like all good travelers, it picked up new influences and adapted. When European settlers, particularly the British and French, came to North America, they brought their culinary traditions with them. And guess what they brought? Pies! Lots and lots of pies.

In America, the pot pie really found its footing. It became a quintessential dish, especially in the colder months. Think of those wide-open spaces, the farms, the need for substantial, warming meals. Pot pie fit the bill perfectly.

Joanna Gaines Chicken Pot Pie: Comfort Food Classic from Magnolia Table
Joanna Gaines Chicken Pot Pie: Comfort Food Classic from Magnolia Table

And you know what’s funny? It’s still so popular today. We have the classic chicken pot pie, which is probably the undisputed champion. That tender chicken, those sweet peas and carrots, the creamy sauce, all tucked under that flaky, golden crust. It’s a masterpiece of simplicity. A culinary hug.

But then there are the variations! Oh, the glorious variations. Beef pot pie, with its rich, savory gravy. Turkey pot pie, often a favorite after Thanksgiving, using up those leftovers in the most delicious way possible. Even vegetable pot pies, packed with all sorts of goodness. The possibilities are, dare I say, endless?

And let's not forget the crust. While the original 'coffins' were tough, modern pot pies often feature a delicate, buttery, flaky puff pastry. Or a tender, shortcrust pastry. Whichever it is, that crust is crucial. It's the crowning glory, the edible lid that seals in all that deliciousness. That moment when you break through the crust with your spoon and the steam rises… pure bliss, right?

It’s interesting to think about how this dish has evolved from a practical food container to a symbol of home-cooked comfort. It’s a testament to how food can tell a story. A story of necessity, of ingenuity, of love, and of course, of deliciousness.

Chicken Pot Pie - The Ultimate Comfort Food - Saving You Dinero
Chicken Pot Pie - The Ultimate Comfort Food - Saving You Dinero

You see it everywhere now, don't you? In diners, in home kitchens, even in the freezer aisle (though, let's be honest, the homemade ones are always superior, right? No judgment, just saying!). It's a dish that transcends generations. My grandma probably made pot pies, and I bet your grandma did too. It’s a culinary heirloom.

And why is it still so beloved? I think it’s that feeling of being taken care of. It’s warm. It’s filling. It’s familiar. It’s the kind of food that makes you want to curl up on the sofa with a good book or share with your favorite people. It’s uncomplicated, yet incredibly satisfying. It’s the ultimate comfort food, no question.

So, next time you’re reaching for that pot pie, whether it’s a store-bought shortcut or a labor of love from your own oven, take a moment. Think about its journey. From a tough medieval 'coffin' to the flaky, golden delight we know and love today. It’s a history that’s as rich and satisfying as the filling itself. And that, my friend, is pretty darn cool.

It’s funny how a simple dish can have such a long and varied past. It just goes to show, some things are just timeless. And a good pot pie? That’s definitely one of them. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I think I’m suddenly craving one. Anyone want to join me for a slice?

You might also like →